A column on punchng.com asks whether Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s position on the transatlantic slave trade represents a British consensus. In an opinion piece published ahead of a recent Commonwealth meeting, Burnham wrote that some have called for financial reparations. He said he does not think British people today can be held liable for historical wrongs, however heinous, that happened in a different age under different laws and in which they played no personal part.

Burnham said he was offering a structured dialogue with those affected by the trade, and that listening to calls for a formal apology would form part of that dialogue. At the Commonwealth meeting he told a journalist that he wanted any dialogue to be about trade, collaborations and new ideas, adding that this would benefit the UK.

The columnist argues that ruling out liability in advance leaves unclear what the dialogue, and any apology, would be about. The writer says Burnham treats the reparations question as financial only, and reads a planned apology as forced rather than voluntary. The column calls the remarks about liability, and the phrase however heinous, undiplomatic, and asks whether a British official with a diplomatic background saw the piece before it was published.

The writer says the prime minister’s view is not a national consensus. The column sets apart British citizens of Commonwealth origin who would support reparations, private citizens in the UK who have made personal reparations in Africa because of forebears involved in the trade, other UK citizens who have joined calls for reparations, and some senior members of the Church of England. Those church figures, the column says, admit historical wrongs and have set aside funds in a reparations package to be spent in England. The writer notes that some people applaud the liability comment and others do not.

The column recalls that the transatlantic slave trade involved the movement of some 12 million enslaved Africans, sold as plantation workers and domestic workers. Britain and Portugal led that trade and were responsible for about 70 percent of all Africans exported. According to the UK national archives, Britain alone transported 3.1 million Africans to British colonies in the Caribbean, the Americas and other countries, and their labour produced goods that built wealth in Europe. British abolitionists began campaigning in 1787, and Parliament passed the Slave Trade Act in 1807. The column says Burnham’s piece also set out the role of his compatriots in abolition.

The writer argues that the debate predates Burnham and will outlast his time in office, as it did for his predecessors. The column urges him to use more diplomatic language with Commonwealth leaders and to leave the question of historical wrongs for later determination, saying much of the Commonwealth is already looking ahead.