The Judicial Committee of the United Kingdom Privy Council on 10 November allowed an appeal by Jason Jones, a gay man, and dismissed a cross-appeal by Trinidad and Tobago’s attorney general. In a unanimous ruling, the court held that sections 13 and 16 of the Sexual Offences Act 1986 infringed Jones’s fundamental rights under the Constitution “and must be interpreted subject to the Constitution so as to make it clear that they do not apply to criminalise private, consensual sexual relations between adults of the same sex”.

Jones had asked the Privy Council, at the end of a long legal battle, for declarations that those sections breach his constitutional rights. Section 13 prohibits “buggery”. Section 16 prohibits sex acts other than sexual intercourse, with an exception for acts carried out in private between a man and a woman who are both over 16 and consent.

On Wednesday, Jamaica Coalition for a Healthy Society president Dr Wayne West told the Jamaica Observer that the group would examine the ruling further. He described it as ridiculous and devoid of reason, and said that if it were used as a precedent it would result in chaos for Caribbean societies. He said his group and the Church recognise the rule of law, but that societies should not follow what he called the British practice of running society on desire and passion rather than reason, design and purpose.

West questioned what he called a so-called right to buggery, arguing that men and women are designed with a purpose to reproduce. Citing Aristotle’s statement that “Law is reason, free of passion”, he said the Privy Council ruling was about passion because it did not entertain design and purpose in the natural order, and that law based on passion or desire leads toward chaos. He pointed to events leading up to the 2025 UK Supreme Court ruling on the legal definition of a woman as an example, and said the issue is public policy rather than private conduct.

He urged Jamaica’s Parliament to treat the Privy Council ruling as free of reason and based on desire. He said that using it as a precedent would, in time, leave adults unable to say what a woman is, as he argued is happening in places such as the UK. He said final courts of appeal have a purpose under the rule of law, but that Parliament must still be able to call a ruling ridiculous and protect society in a constitutional democracy where a court can review an act of Parliament.

The JCHS was one of 10 interested parties that opposed a constitutional challenge to Jamaica’s anti-sodomy law by gay rights activist Maurice Tomlinson. In 2023 the Constitutional Court ruled that the savings law clause in Jamaica’s Charter of Rights bars the courts from enquiring into whether three provisions of the country’s sex-offence laws breach the constitutional rights of homosexuals, and said the remedy is for Parliament. Sections 13(12) and 18 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which in 2011 replaced the Bill of Rights chapter, immunise existing laws that criminalise sexual relations between men and preclude legal recognition of homosexual unions.

Tomlinson, a married Jamaican who lives in Canada and frequents the island, filed a Supreme Court claim in 2015 challenging sections 76, 77 and 79 of the 1864 Offences Against the Person Act. He argued that criminalising homosexuality breaches his constitutional rights and drives LGBTQ people underground. The government and 10 church groups opposed the claim, arguing that the savings law clause left the court without jurisdiction.