Prime Minister Andy Burnham has put Britain's relationship with the European Union back at the centre of government, telling his cabinet that the country ended up with a harder Brexit than people voted for and that no sensible person thinks the deal negotiated by the Conservatives is working.
On Thursday he will, for the first time, meet European leaders in Dublin who could be pivotal as he sets out his vision for Britain's future in the bloc. He is then due to give a foreign-policy speech in which Europe is a central theme, before travelling to Brussels for a UK-EU summit to sign new agreements on food, energy and youth mobility. He told ministers that the government will take opportunities that make people in this country better off.
That agenda sits behind his decision to open a longer-term argument about rejoining the EU single market, and the freedom of movement that would bring, and even about rejoining the EU itself. The ambition is dividing the cabinet and the Labour Party.
Some welcome the shift, including MPs from constituencies that previously backed Brexit. Angela Rayner is understood to have pressed former prime minister Sir Keir Starmer to be bolder on Brexit since at least autumn 2022. The housing secretary is said to have insisted that Labour keep its manifesto red lines against a return to the single market, the customs union or freedom of movement, while remaining open to changing those lines at the next election.
Another cabinet minister said the best thing in politics is to tell the truth, that Brexit has been hugely damaging to Britain, and that the government is racing to catch up with the public rather than leading the conversation. Others are more wary. A former minister called the strategy high risk. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has warned about the costs and consequences both of rejoining the EU and of staying out. Business and Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds supports getting closer to the EU and discussing the long-term relationship, but he has warned against joining the customs union and is unsure about rejoining, citing uncertain terms and the rise of nationalist parties in several European countries.
Former prime minister Lord Cameron told Bloomberg's Mishal Husain that starting a conversation about rejoining would be very long and painful. He warned that flirting with rejoining could weaken Burnham's attempt to renegotiate the Conservative Brexit deal, because EU countries might conclude there was little point in offering a good partnership if Britain was going to rejoin anyway.
Labour opinion does not split on predictable lines. A Scottish Labour MP who opposed Brexit and represents a heavily Remain-voting seat called the approach a real problem, asking how an MP could tell constituents that the 2014 Scottish referendum settled independence for a generation while arguing that the 2016 referendum is not settled. The MP's view is that democracy should be accepted. Opposition has not become a public rebellion, though Stoke-on-Trent MP Gareth Snell, whose constituency voted 69.4% to leave, told the BBC's Westminster Hour that reopening the debate would monopolise an awful lot of time in Parliament and government. Two of the Labour MPs most unhappy about the shift insisted there are no plans for organised criticism and described their position as wait and see. That truce is likely to fracture if the prime minister's poll lead begins to slide.
Other parties are also recalibrating. The Conservatives oppose any future alignment with EU rules. Leader Kemi Badenoch has called that a red line that would take the country backwards, and she has pledged that a future Conservative government would withdraw the UK from the European Convention on Human Rights. Some Conservative MPs fear Burnham's move could again divide their voters, including affluent voters in the south of England whom the party has been trying to win back and who see his economic offer as too left-wing. One Conservative MP said some of those voters are only just giving the party a hearing again after Brexit and will now keep being reminded of it.
Liberal Democrats, long the most pro-European of the largest Westminster parties, fear that position could be drowned out. Reform UK says it is very bullish about Brexit returning to debate despite polling that suggests public sentiment has shifted since 2016. A party strategist said that if Burnham wants to fight an election on a £40bn bill to rejoin, open-door immigration and less control over laws and courts, Reform is very up for that. The party expects an anti-Brexit coalition to form around Labour and Brexit supporters to gather around Reform as the most anti-EU party.


