Sebastián Carassai’s Beyond the War, published by Cambridge University Press, argues that growing Argentine nationalism and Britain’s increasing separation of the Falkland Islands from the mainland let relations between governments displace relations between neighbors. The 372-page book costs $50. Those who side with Argentina call the islands the Malvinas.
Before the 1982 war, family lines crossed the South Atlantic. Falkland Islander Pamela McLeod and her Argentine husband, Reynaldo Reid, left for a belated honeymoon in Buenos Aires in November 1970. Argentine reporters and cameramen were waiting. The press treated the marriage as evidence of bonds with the British-held islands, and the trip became a 15-day tour of television studios, ministries and political offices.
Reid’s father was Scottish and his mother English. He was born in Argentina, had Chilean sisters and an Argentine brother, and later spent much of his life with McLeod in Stanley. The couple had seven daughters and two sons, the youngest born in 1981. In Stanley, Reid became an informal Argentine delegate and co-ran what is now the third-oldest bar in the islands. After more than a decade there, he told the Argentine press that the community had accepted him as another member.
McLeod, raised in the rural Falklands by families who took turns looking after her, told Carassai she had lived a homeless life before married life in Stanley. A few days after the Argentine invasion in April 1982, she and seven of her children flew to Argentina to avoid the conflict. Two older children were already studying on the continent. The family meant to return; the eldest daughter, training as a teacher in Buenos Aires, told a television program she planned to work at a school in Stanley. McLeod later told Carassai they went for a few days and stayed thirty years. After Reid’s death she relied on support from Jehovah’s Witnesses while caring for what she called a family of refugees. From the 1990s many of the children, by then married to Argentines, began moving back, and McLeod returned to Stanley with a new Argentine husband.
Artist James Peck, from the Falklands, was married to an Argentine woman and had two children, then became estranged from them in the late 2000s. During that family crisis he accepted an Argentine identity card. Then-president Cristina Fernández de Kirchner chaired the ceremony, and official publicity described him as the first islander to receive an Argentine DNI after the conflict. Carassai says the situation was overwhelming for Peck, whom many Falkland Islanders regarded as a traitor, and that the Argentine government used a father in distress to score political points. Peck told The Guardian in 2016 that he felt Argentina had cast a big shadow over his soul and that his aim had been to fix his family and move on. After four years he cut up the document, posted a photo of the pieces on Facebook and returned to Stanley. He told The Guardian he later realized real people did not seem to matter and that the episode was about making a statement on the islands.
Carassai also traces economic links that long predated the war. Islanders, who often called the nearby mainland the coast, helped establish sheep farming on Patagonian estancias and carried agricultural know-how across the South Atlantic. In the late 19th century Argentina recruited Falklanders for sparsely populated Patagonia. In 1886 the governor of Santa Cruz, Carlos María Moyano, married Falkland Islander Ethel Turner and, with support from Buenos Aires, promised cheap leases to farmers who would move. Surnames familiar in the islands, including Halliday, Rudd, Scott, Blake, Patterson, Hamilton, Waldron and Wood, became common in Patagonia. The largest ranch, Cóndor, covered 200,000 hectares and became the headquarters of the Patagonian Sheep Farming Company, for many years the most important livestock company in southern Argentina.
Trade ran both ways. The Falkland Islands Gazette reported imports of animals, particularly horses, from Patagonia, Argentina and South America. By the 1970s Argentina was supplying the islands with coal, oil, kerosene and diesel. Carassai describes Argentina’s construction of an airstrip as the most important work: it cost about 750,000 pounds, more than $12 million in today’s money, and made regular air links possible. In 1971 the British and Argentine governments signed the Communications Agreement, and scheduled flights became commonplace. Children went to Argentina for secondary school, patients traveled to Argentine hospitals, Argentine teachers worked in Stanley, and tourists arrived from the mainland. Carassai argues the projects were meant to improve life on the islands and to signal to islanders, Britain and the United Nations that Argentina could be trusted to look after the island population.
Less than a year after regular flights began, The Falkland Islands Times warned about the pace of change. Writing of the years before the agreement, Rev. Robin Forrester said isolation had kept strangers from arriving unawares, while a weekly plane service brought many outsiders and a faster pace of life.
This year President Javier Milei renewed Argentina’s claim, pledging tougher sanctions on companies operating around the Falklands and more funding for a naval base in Tierra del Fuego. Before the war the territory barely registered with the British public; few Britons could have placed it on a map, and some servicemen sent to the conflict initially assumed the Falklands lay off Scotland. Europeans established their first permanent settlement on the islands in 1764. Carassai’s account is that migration, trade, tourism and family ties did not erase the sovereignty dispute, and that the dispute did not make war inevitable.


